How To Get Out of a Non-Compete Agreement

ContractsCounsel has assisted 170 clients with noncompete agreements and maintains a network of 165 employment lawyers available daily. These lawyers collectively have 38 reviews to help you choose the best lawyer for your needs.

Getting out of a non-compete agreement entails navigating legal considerations and mediating with the involved parties to begin engaging in similar businesses. A non-compete agreement is a statutory arrangement in which one individual decides not to join or initiate a similar job or business in competition with another entity. Moreover, since the effectiveness of these strategies varies depending on the specific circumstances, it is reasonable to seek professional legal guidance to ensure taking the appropriate steps in particular situations. This blog post will discuss the essentials for getting out of a non-compete agreement and other relevant aspects.

Steps to Get Out of a Non-Compete Agreement

Non-compete agreements, a standard feature in employment contracts, have become increasingly prevalent in today's competitive business environment. While serving a legitimate purpose, instances may arise where employees seek relief from the constraints imposed by a non-compete agreement. The following steps outline a rational approach to getting out of a non-compete agreement.

Examine the Non-compete Contract. Initiate the procedure by comprehensively reviewing the contract. Analyze specific phrases such as the duration of the non-compete period, geographical restrictions, and forbidden activities. Understanding the complexities of the agreement is necessary for preparing a strategic plan to challenge its enforceability.
Consult with an Employment Attorney. Engaging legal counsel is crucial when navigating the complexities of non-compete agreements. Employment attorneys specializing in labor laws offer valuable insights into the enforceability of specific contracts. They can assess the reasonableness of restrictions, consideration adequacy, and other legal defenses' potential applicability.
Evaluate Enforceability. Given the variability of employment laws across states, understanding the enforceability of non-compete agreements requires a state-specific analysis. While some states inflict strict constraints, restricting the extent and duration of these agreements, others adopt a more tolerant approach. Acquaintance with appropriate state regulations is essential when evaluating the enforceability of a non-compete agreement, especially if it appears overly restrictive or infringes on state regulations.
Assess Overbreadth and Excessive Restrictions. Tribunals often examine non-compete contracts to ensure they are balanced and relaxed. It may be considered unenforceable if an agreement inflicts restrictions beyond what is required to safeguard the employer's legitimate interests. For instance, a ban on working in the entire industry for an extended period may be overly broad.
Negotiate with the Employer. Consider negotiation as a potential resolution. Employers may be open to modifying non-compete terms, especially if enforcing the original terms seems challenging. Engaging in a diplomatic discussion with the employer and proposing reasonable modifications can be a constructive way to resolve the issue without resorting to legal action.
Demonstrate a Lack of Consideration. A non-compete agreement must involve adequate consideration for both parties. If the employee can show inadequate consideration, such as not receiving a job offer, promotion, or access to proprietary information in exchange for the agreement, it may weaken its enforceability.
Prove Unreasonable Economic Hardship. Demonstrating that enforcing the agreement would cause unreasonable economic hardship is another potential avenue for escaping a non-compete agreement. It could involve situations where the deal restricts the ability to find gainful employment or pursue opportunities aligning with the skills and experience.
Show a Material Breach by the Employer. If the employer breaches the employment contract or fails to fulfill obligations, it can strengthen the position when challenging the non-compete agreement. Courts may be more inclined to invalidate the agreement if the employer has not upheld their end of the bargain.
Seek Injunction Relief. If negotiations prove futile and legal action becomes necessary, seeking injunction relief is an option. An injunction prohibits the employer from enforcing the non-compete agreement. To obtain an injunction, demonstrate the likelihood of success and the irreparable harm enforcing the agreement would cause.
Challenge in Court. As a last resort, consider court action. Present a strong claim supported by evidence and legal arguments. Employment attorneys can advise clients through the legal process, from filing the initial complaint to presenting their claims in court. In addition, it is necessary to weigh the potential advantages against the expenses, considering that court actions can be time-consuming and costly.

Consequences of Violating a Non-Compete Agreement

Employees who infringe on non-compete contracts may face various contractual and legal consequences. Understanding these potential repercussions is imperative for employees to get out of non-compete contracts. Some consequences of violating a non-compete agreement are as follows:

Injunctive Relief: One of the substantial repercussions for individuals violating non-compete contracts involves the probability of injunctive relief. Courts can issue an injunction—a legal memorandum restraining the employee from participating in competitive activities within a specified timeframe and defined geographical boundaries. This restriction can substantially hinder the employee's prospects of finding alternative employment and continuing their work in the chosen field.
Damages and Monetary Consequences: Employees who infringe non-compete contracts may face monetary penalties, encompassing compensatory damages, consequential damages, and, in specific circumstances, punitive damages. The kinds and amounts of injuries depend on aspects such as the nature of the infringement, the monetary harm imposed upon the former employer, and the relevant state laws.
Enforcement by Liquidated Damages : Certain non-compete agreements incorporate clauses stipulating liquidated damages—a predetermined sum the employee must pay in case of a breach. Courts meticulously review these clauses to ascertain their reasonableness and ensure they don't function as punitive measures. If deemed fair, employees may be obligated to pay the specified amount as compensation for the harm resulting from their breach.
Trade Secret Misappropriation Claims: Non-compliance with a non-compete agreement may entail misusing or disclosing a former employer's trade secrets. In such instances, employees could face additional legal actions for trade secret misappropriation, leading to damages and the potential for criminal charges, especially if the misappropriation involves intentional and malicious conduct.
Career Implications: Beyond legal ramifications, individuals violating non-compete agreements may encounter enduring career consequences. Damage to reputation strained professional relationships, and restricted opportunities within the industry can all stem from breaching these agreements. Employers might share information about the breach with industry peers, complicating the employee's future employment prospects.